One of the greatest days of the year is upon us as Selection Sunday has finally arrived. There are not many better things in sports than seeing your team’s name pop up in the bracket during the Selection Show. The exhilaration of knowing you made the NCAA Tournament, or the agony and anger if your team is not one of the 68 mentioned. It’s all about the journey to get there and the path your team has to potentially reach a Final Four. As a bracketologist, I care deeply about where teams should be seeded, but as a coach, player or fan, what matters more is the region you are placed in and the path forward. I cannot wait to see this bracket unfold!
For a few hours on Saturday, it looked like we were going to see a big shakeup at the top of the bracket. Florida was the final No. 1 seed heading into yesterday and the Gators were beaten badly by Vanderbilt in the semifinals of the SEC tournament. There was a real chance that Florida would no longer be a No. 1 seed because UConn was playing St. John’s for the Big East championship and Houston was in the Big 12 finals against Arizona. If either UConn or Houston won, it’s quite possible one of the two would have been a No. 1 seed. But that did not happen. UConn ran into a buzzsaw at MSG against the Johnnies and Houston dropped a tough one to Arizona. As a result, Florida (South region) remains a No. 1 seed and will join Duke (East), Michigan (Midwest) and Arizona (West).
I feel confident about UConn, Houston and Iowa State all as No. 2 seeds. The final No. 1 seed could come down to three Big Ten teams in Michigan State, Purdue and Illinois. I actually think the Boilermakers have the best overall resume, plus are playing Sunday in the Big Ten championship game, but Michigan State did win at Purdue and we know that head-to-head is definitely a thing with this selection committee. And Sparty gets it over Illinois since they are 9-6 Quad 1, while the Illini are just 7-8.
When it comes to the No. 3 line there are numerous Big Ten teams on it, including Purdue, Illinois and Nebraska. The Cornhuskers have dropped back down to earth of late, but still boast a WAB ranking of No. 11 and SOR ranking of No. 7. Gonzaga rounds out the No. 3 seeds as it ended up as WCC regular season and tournament champs, along with having top 12 predictive metrics across the board.
A few days ago, I thought the No. 4 seeds were going to be a little trickier than they ended up being. Virginia finished 17-5 against Quad 1 and Quad 2 opponents and advanced to the ACC tournament championship game before running into the machine that is Duke. The Cavaliers also have a strong WAB ranking of No. 7. Vanderbilt beat Florida earlier today and improved to 10-6 against Quad 1 and Quad 2 opponents. The Commodores also have top 16 metrics across the board.
Alabama is the next No. 4 seed as it also has top 16 metrics and has wins away from home over St. John’s, Illinois and Tennessee. That win over St. John’s is crucial because the Red Storm are one of the teams that the Crimson Tide are competing with for a No. 4 seed. The final team in the top 16 is Kansas. The Jayhawks have wins over Arizona, Iowa State, Houston and Tennessee. Those are some really strong wins and even though their predictive metrics are hovering close to 20, these key wins are enough to prevent them from not being a protected seed.
The only real suspense that is left before we get to see the actual bracket is whether or not VCU is able to win the A-10 tournament or if Dayton becomes the automatic bid. VCU will still be in play for an at-large bid, but why chance it when it can seal the deal with a win today. I will be making final updates to my bracket throughout the day and once all games are completed.
Here are some thoughts regarding today’s bracket:
- My last four teams in the field ended up being Santa Clara, Miami (OH), Texas and SMU. SMU was the team that I was going to knock out of the field had we seen one more bid-stealer. Missouri and Miami (OH) each have poor predictive metrics; Texas is only three games over .500 and has a dreadful record against Quad 1-Quad 2 and SMU and has worst SOR of any at-large team and has an injury question with BJ Edwards. The Mustangs were just 1-4 since he got injured, but the school came out with a statement saying Edwards will be back for the NCAA Tournament.
- I think UCF has a wide range of seeding outcomes. The Knights have a resume metric average of 33.3, but also possess a BPI ranking of No. 57. They have strong wins over Texas Tech, Kansas, TCU, at Texas A&M and at BYU. I felt like the strong wins and particularly their strong resume metrics could lift them onto the No. 9 seed line. If the selection committee decides to seed them strictly based on predictive metrics, then UCF could even end up playing in the First Four in Dayton.
- Iowa is a team I feel like has a bit of an overrated resume. The best part about the Hawkeyes resume is that they have a 27.0 predictive metric average. However, they do not have any wins over tournament teams away from home. Their resume metrics average out to 42.3 which is good enough to be called a tournament team, but not really good enough to be a single digit seed. On top of that, they also have two Quad 3 losses, are just 1-8 against Quad 1A opponents and also have a poor nonconference strength-of-schedule. As a result, I have them as a No. 10 seed, even though their predictive metrics tell a different story.
- Wisconsin finished the season with a set of ridiculously strong wins. The Badgers own wins at Michigan, at Illinois, at Purdue, home against Michigan State and against Illinois in Chicago. Their metrics put them as a No. 6 seed, but with those strong wins, there’s no question Wisconsin belongs as a No. 5 seed.
- I would love to see St. John’s get a No. 4 seed after winning the Big East regular season and tournament, but I just think it’s going to be hard for it to jump teams like Alabama, Kansas, Vanderbilt or even Wisconsin. The problem is, the Red Storm did not produce any significant wins in nonconference play and the Big East was not nearly as good (at least the top half) as some of these other power conferences.
Last 4 Byes
Iowa, Texas A&M, NC State, Missouri
Last 4 In
Santa Clara, Miami (OH), Texas, SMU
First 4 Out
Oklahoma, Auburn, San Diego State, Indiana
Next 4 Out
New Mexico, Stanford, Oklahoma State, California
Bracketology
Howard Bison
Long Island Sharks
Prairie View A&M Panthers
Siena Saints
Saint Louis Billikens
Akron Zips
California Baptist Lancers
Tennessee State Tigers
Iowa Hawkeyes
Idaho Vandals
Florida Gators
Queens Royals
High Point Panthers
North Dakota State Bison
Troy Trojans
Houston Cougars
Kennesaw State Owls
Howard Bison
/
Saint Mary's Gaels
Villanova Wildcats
Northern Iowa Panthers
Hawaii Rainbow Warriors
Tennessee Volunteers
VCU Rams
Penn Quakers
Furman Paladins
Long Island Sharks
/
Prairie View A&M Panthers
TCU Horned Frogs
McNeese Cowboys
Hofstra Pride
North Carolina Tar Heels
Wright State Raiders
UMBC Retrievers
Bids by Conference
| Conference | No. of Bids |
|---|---|
| SEC | 10 |
| Big Ten | 9 |
| ACC | 8 |
| Big 12 | 8 |
| Big East | 3 |
| WCC | 3 |
| A-10 | 2 |