The NCAA selection committee revealed its top 16 teams on Saturday and I’ve never been so happy. My happiness doesn’t come from the results displayed; it comes from the fact that committee chairman Keith Gill gave us what I’ve always been asking for. Clear, concise and logical reasoning behind why each team was seeded where it ended up being seeded. Ultimately, I would love to get a similar breakdown after the actual 68-team bracket is revealed — nothing beats transparency!
As far as the actual seeds revealed, I do not have any real issues with what the selection committee did. The top line featured Michigan, Duke, Arizona and Iowa State. The Cyclones finished ahead of Houston due to the fact that they were 4-1 against Quad 1A opponents, while Houston was just 2-3. The Cyclones’ case was also helped due to the fact that they had just beaten Houston earlier in the week. UConn, Illinois and Purdue joined Houston on the No. 2 seed line.
The No. 3 seed line went as expected with Florida, Kansas, Nebraska and Gonzaga. One big question I had heading into this reveal was how the selection committee would treat Texas Tech now that JT Toppin is out for the season. The Red Raiders hadn’t played any games without him up to that point, but Keith Gill said that the committee had them as a No. 3 seed prior to the injury and dropped them one seed line to a No. 4 to account for it. I don’t have a problem with this, as Texas Tech has wins this season over Houston, Arizona and Duke. The No. 4 seed line was rounded out with Michigan State, Vanderbilt and Virginia.
Even though we learned so much from the top-16 reveal, a lot happened on the court that changed things. First off, Duke beat Michigan on a neutral court, which means the Blue Devils are now the overall No. 1 seed. Iowa State, Houston and Illinois all lost, while UConn won at Villanova. Because of this, the Huskies jumped Iowa State to take the final No. 1 seed for now.
Other interesting results on Saturday that affected the top 16 teams were Kansas getting upset at home by Cincinnati, Tennessee winning at Vanderbilt and Texas Tech dominating Kansas State in its first game without JT Toppin.
Here are some thoughts regarding today’s bracket:
- Auburn came up with a significant win against Kentucky on Saturday, which elevated the Tigers to a No. 10 seed. A loss would have dropped them to just one game over .500 and no team has ever received an at-large bid while being one game over. Auburn doesn’t even need quality wins; it just needs wins. The Tigers are now 15-12 overall and will probably get an at-large bid with two more victories this season. Their final four games are at Oklahoma, Ole Miss, LSU and at Alabama.
- USC had a head-scratching loss at home to Oregon on Saturday night. This was the Trojans’ second Quad 3 loss of the season and they are now hanging on by a thread for an at-large bid. A major positive on their resume is the fact that they are 9-7 against Quad 1 and Quad 2 opponents. USC also has the No. 46 WAB ranking, which isn’t great, but it’s still currently better than many other bubble teams. The Trojans are now in my last four in.
- UCLA started the day on Saturday as my last team in the field, but it ended the day with one of the biggest wins of the weekend as it upset Illinois 95-94 in overtime. The Bruins also have a big win over Purdue and now find themselves as a No. 10 seed. UCLA has the No. 38 WAB ranking, which puts it safely in the field for the time being.
- What is going on with Clemson? The Tigers have now lost four games in a row after losing at home to Florida State on Saturday. Their No. 41 SOR is getting a bit worrisome and their overall projected seed is dropping at a rapid pace. I have them as a No. 9 seed right now, but their next two games are against Louisville and at North Carolina. Winning one of those games would be ideal. Go 0-2 and things will get messy for Clemson.
- I currently have St. John’s as a No. 5 seed and it’s been on that seed-line for quite some time. Well, the Red Storm have a chance to get off that line this week as they head to UConn on Wednesday. A season sweep over the Huskies would likely lift the Johnnies onto the No. 4 line. The one thing that has really limited their ceiling is the fact that they only have two wins over projected at-large teams and both of those wins came in Big East play.
- Florida continues to play like one of the best teams in the country. The Gators have won seven games in a row and have top-five predictive metrics across the board. I don’t think a No. 1 seed will be in play for this team due to the fact that they don’t have the type of high-end wins needed, but I would be surprised if the Gators don’t end up as a No. 2 seed on Selection Sunday.
Last 4 Byes
UCLA, Saint Mary’s, Texas, Missouri
Last 4 In
Indiana, TCU, Santa Clara, USC
First 4 Out
New Mexico, California, Ohio State, Virginia Tech
Next 4 Out
VCU, West Virginia, San Diego State, Seton Hall
Bracketology
Howard Bison
Tennessee State Tigers
Indiana Hoosiers
UMBC Retrievers
Bethune-Cookman Wildcats
TCU Horned Frogs
Long Island Sharks
Utah Valley Wolverines
Saint Louis Billikens
North Dakota State Bison
Houston Cougars
Navy Midshipmen
Appalachian State Mountaineers
Belmont Bruins
North Carolina Tar Heels
Indiana Hoosiers
/
East Tennessee State Buccaneers
Merrimack Warriors
Howard Bison
/
Tennessee State Tigers
Tennessee Volunteers
High Point Panthers
TCU Horned Frogs
/
Florida Gators
Austin Peay Governors
Villanova Wildcats
Portland State Vikings
Bethune-Cookman Wildcats
/
UMBC Retrievers
Iowa Hawkeyes
Liberty Flames
UNC Wilmington Seahawks
Miami Ohio Red Hawks
Hawaii Rainbow Warriors
Saint Mary's Gaels
Wright State Raiders
Bids by Conference
| Conference | No. of Bids |
|---|---|
| SEC | 11 |
| Big Ten | 10 |
| ACC | 8 |
| Big 12 | 8 |
| Big East | 3 |
| WCC | 3 |