The college basketball season has now been underway for a fortnight. That means it’s time to start leaning into computer rankings to assemble my weekly AP Top 25 ballot.
Too early for that, you say? P’shaw! It’s never too early to be nerdy. My policy with computer rankings is that they’re useful, but not gospel. Yet, over the years, I have found that when the rankings diverge significantly from my own opinions, the numbers usually turn out to be correct — and prescient.
We also have the advantage of relying on two very different methods of assessment. The first is KenPom, which is a predictive (read: gambling) metric that is currently based heavily on data from last season. The second is BartTorvik, which uses much the same formula as KenPom except it can be data-sorted to include only games from this season. (I’ve urged Ken Pomeroy for years to add this feature to his site, but he is a very stubborn nerd.)
As I list each team below, I’m including each one’s position on KenPom and BartTorvik for this season only. The numbers in parentheses indicate where they were ranked on my ballot last week.
Here, then, is the (correct) order of the top 25 teams in men’s college basketball, as filed to the Associated Press Sunday night.

DROPPED OUT: Louisville (8) 35-75; Tennessee (12) 36-89; Arkansas (16) 35-80; Kentucky (18) 55-128; Indiana (20) 46-57
ALMOST FAMOUS: Baylor (32-22), Missouri (23-25), Cincinnati (26-34), Xavier (27-9), Ole Miss (28-7), Utah State (31-18), Minnesota (32-23), Grand Canyon (42-52)
Notes on the votes
• So here’s the way I incorporated the analytics. I laid out my order based on previous rankings, head-to-head results, and my general assessment of the teams. Then I scrubbed the list based on the computer rankings. If a team was ranked ahead of the team above in both metrics, I moved it up a spot. Teams kept sliding up and down accordingly. As you can see, for Team A to be ahead of Team B, it had to be ranked ahead in at least one of the metrics.
• There was only one exception to this rule, and that’s Memphis. I moved the Tigers into my rankings after their opening night win over Iowa State in South Dakota. I also dropped the Cyclones for the loss since Memphis was unranked. Then when Vanderbilt blitzed Memphis by 24 points, I moved the Tigers out.
On Sunday, however, Memphis somehow came from 18 points down eight minutes into the game at home against Louisville to beat the Cardinals by 20. As a result I a) moved Memphis back into my top 25, given that last week I had the Cards at No. 8; b) moved Louisville out, mostly due to their horrific rankings; and c) moved Iowa State back in. The Cyclones played Memphis tough, and as you can see KenPom has them at No. 15.
Like I said, computer rankings are useful, not gospel. I follow the numbers until I don’t.
As for my Almost Famous list, Baylor came a whisker from getting a number next to its name, but the Bears couldn’t quite pull off the win over Texas in San Antonio on Sunday. They will be in the Players Era 16 over Thanksgiving week, beginning with a game against Alabama that Tuesday. And keep your eye on Xavier and Ole Miss, two teams that are currently in the top 10 at BartTorvik. Xavier has a home game against Iowa on Friday and then will head to The Bahamas for the Battle 4 Atlantis. The Rebels are at the Maui Invitational over Thanksgiving.
• It is fascinating to see which teams surprise you by being ranked so high in the computers, and which ones are ranked unexpectedly low. On the high side, you have Nebraska and Texas A&M. The Cornhuskers handled Providence by nine points at Mohegan Sun, and on Sunday they dominated a good Boise State team in South Dakota 102-75. Bucky McMillan’s Aggies are also 4-0 with a 19-point win last Thursday over Oklahoma State. The Pokes have an interesting stretch coming up against TCU on the road, and then head to the Battle 4 Atlantis to play Xavier and Marquette.
• Houston is a big-time analytics darling with little to show for it besides wins over LaSalle, Cal and Jacksonville State. They will be in Las Vegas this week for the Players Era 8 with a likely semifinal matchup against Florida on tap for Wednesday. Should that happen we’ll find out a lot more about just how good this team is.
• Vanderbilt is also an analytics darling — again — and the Commodores’ win over Memphis looks even better after the Tigers dominated Louisville. Andy Katz and I interviewed Vandy coach Mark Byington for the Hoops HQ Show, so look for that episode on Tuesday. The Commodores have an interesting test coming up a week from Tuesday when they play Ohio State in Columbus.
• Virginia continues to impress me as a team that is very capable of challenging Duke for the ACC title. The Cavs embarrassed Arkansas in Washington, DC, on Nov. 8 and they pulled out a tough win at Maryland on Friday night. They’ll be tested again during the Battle 4 Atlantis over Thanksgiving. They also host Kentucky in Charlottesville on Dec. 2 as part of the ACC-SEC Challenge.
• For all the hand wringing and pearl clutching, LSU has — dare I say it — a strong-ass roster. The Tigers came back from 13 points down in the second half to eke out a dramatic 81-80 win over Gonzaga in Spokane. Somehow, Will Wade was able to get his fifth-year seniors eligible, and one of them, Donovan Dent, hit the three-point dagger in the closing seconds. Circle Dec. 13, because that’s the date LSU plays Houston at the Toyota Center in Houston.
• It was an easy choice to drop Kentucky from my ballot. It was bad enough for the Wildcats to get humiliated by Kansas by 20 points at the Champions Classic. They followed that up by needing an Alex Wilkins near-buzzer beating three to escape Northern Arizona in Rupp Arena on Friday night with a 78-77 win. The Lumberjacks came into the game 0-3 and are ranked No. 257 on KenPom. Things won’t get any easier for Kentucky as they play Indiana in Indianapolis on Friday, then go to Virginia on Dec. 2, and then play Louisville and North Carolina in December — not to mention the rigors of the SEC. It will take some time for this team to find its way, but that’s not a problem because Kentucky fans are well known for their patience.
• I would not have expected to drop Arkansas, Tennessee or Indiana from my rankings, and I think Louisville still has a case. But the numbers are the numbers, and there’s a reason those teams are so low in both rankings. There’s an easy and obvious remedy for that, and that’s to win. I’ll be watching.
























